MLB the Show 21 vs RBI Baseball 21: Which Should You Get?

With both games releasing in Spring, which one is right for you?
With both games releasing in Spring, which one is right for you? / Photo Courtesy of MLB

MLB the Show 21 or RBI Baseball 21, what game should you get? Both games are releasing in Spring, the former in April and the latter in March. As the two of them are both part of legendary, historic game franchises, they both have their share of hardcore fans. But what game should YOU be getting?

MLB the Show 21 vs RBI Baseball 21: Which Should You Get?

The Case for MLB The Show 21

Nothing beats the show in terms of quality
Nothing beats the show in terms of quality / Photo Courtesy of San Diego Studios

MLB The Show 21 is undeniable of a higher quality and more depth. It has an in-depth career mode, a very solid franchise mode, and a team-building mode through Diamond Dynasty. The graphics are also better and more polished. At $59.99, the price may be a little intimidating, but for baseball fans out there, The Show 21 is the more detailed, immersive experience.

The Case for RBI Baseball 21

RBI Baseball is far simpler, and that's the point
RBI Baseball is far simpler, and that's the point / Photo Courtesy of MLB

RBI is not as good as the Show in terms of quality. Let's get that out of the way first. That being said, it has its own backyard charm. It's a far simpler game than the Show, and while that means a lesser experience for hardcore baseball fans, it means it's easier to pick up for newcomers. At $29.99, it's half the price as The Show too. Now, The Show does have its own retro mode, but for players looking for a specific arcade-like baseball game, paying half the cost seems like a better choice.

In Conclusion

Which game is right for you ultimately depends on who you are. If you're someone looking for an in-depth baseball game that you can immerse yourself in, and really feel like you're in the world of MLB, The Show is the way to go. Down to even the small details, it's just a better baseball game. If all you care about is quality and how authentic an experience you'll get, The Show is a must.

That being said, the difference in price between the two is definitely worth noting. If you're just looking for a more casual game you can dip into at a lower price, or using a video game as an intro to the sport, RBI Baseball is worth considering. It gives off a more relaxed, newcomer-friendly vibe as well, MLB The Show is the more "ultimate" experience of the two, but that also means it can be more intimidating to get into. If you're unsure about how much time you'll invest into the game and just want to get a taste of baseball through video games, RBI Baseball may be the better choice.